Doesn't Healthy Exercising Always Lead to Lasting Weight Loss?


You'd guess that good, solid exercise, especially the "get sweaty, huff-and-puff kind" would burn up tons of calories and lead to significant and lasting weight-loss?

Wouldn't you?

According to the latest study, the answer is both a definitive Yes and No!

The Latest Studies

Recent evidence from a study conducted by and reported in "The British Journal of Sports Medicine", found evidence to support both positions. According to the researchers, the most comprehensive assessment of the impact of exercise on weight loss to date was conducted by members of an international group of independent researchers known as the Cochrane Collaboration.

The review surveyed 43 individual studies, with the ambition of quantifying the effect that exercise has on weight-loss [2].

Quantity and Quality of Exercise Varies

The amount of exercise prescribed in these studies varied from study to study; from one-half hour per day several days per week to one hour per day, 5 times per week.

Typically, exercise sessions lasted 45 minutes with a frequency of 3-5 times a week. The lengths of the studies ranged between 3 and 12 months.

Measuring Metabolic Rates

The individual studies in this review were designed to measure metabolic rates and energy use.

Several of them directly compared the effect that exercise or diet has on weight loss. Some other studies in this review compared the effect of diet and exercise with diet alone.

Results showed that 'diet only group’ lost between 6.17 pounds (2.8 kg) and 29 pounds (13.6 kg) during the study periods.
The other, the 'diet and exercise group' lost between 7.7 pounds (3.493kg) and 31 pounds (14.06 kg) in weight.

Overall, the 'diet and exercise group' averaged out a slightly better loss of 2.2 pounds or 1 kg over the testing period.
Not too impressive in my book.

An 'Insignificant Loss' When Measured Against the Investment

Think of it this way: Imagine that you diet and exercise for 45 minutes per day, 4 times per week for 6 months and manage to lose 22 pounds. Sounds pretty good, right?

Well, according to the 'diet only' metabolic data -- now affirmed in over 45 studies -- your 'investment' in time, energy, equipment, travel to and from the gym, etc., etc., will have slimmed you only an additional 2.5 pounds.

When you realize that the time you spent a -- whopping 69 hours -- to lose one (1) additional kg in total weight over the same period -- the 'exercise to lose' mantra rings pretty hollow!

So Why Don't Exercise and Weigh-loss Work Togther?

It's not rocket science -- it's just human nature.
When people work-out they generally work up a sizable appetite. It is at that point in the process that the otherwise beautify union of exercise and weight-loss breaks down. Many exerciser / dieters compensate for their sizable hunger by over-eating or add other nutritional supplements like energy bars or energy drinks to the mix and over-shoot their caloric target.

Exercise Has Lots of Great Benefits

Don't get us wrong here! We feel that regular, cardio-vascular and strengthening exercise is a mandatory aspect of good overall physical and mental health.
Even so, it seems equally conclusive that, exercise, coupled with resultant compensatory over-eating or drinking of nutrition or energy drinks is counter productive to solid weight-loss and solid use of time, energy and natural resources.

Have Some Deep Thoughts or Feelings about his Topic?

Do you have an insight or thought we might need to know about this? Share it! Enter your title below and a box will drop down for you to share your thoughts.

If you have a question about the HCG diet, visit our HCG Diet Questions page.

What Other Visitors Have Said

Click below to see contributions from other visitors to this page...

Benefits of exercise on HCG 
How can exercise not be totally benefical. I always burn tons of calories when I go to the gym, shoot some hoops or jog. I don't get it?

Mr. Muscleman 
I cannot beleive that a hard work-out does hardly better for weightloss than dieting by itself. Did you make this up?

Click here to write your own.